- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
You must log in or register to comment.
They should have the players who received medical treatment taken off for 5 minutes as well , might cut down the amount of fake injuries.
Why do people insist on trying to re-invent the wheel? Leave the game rules alone, stop putting your ten cents worth in and fucking it up…
Immediately no
I like the idea of a sin bin. Use it for dives, fake fighting and all that sort of crap. Swearing at the ref.
This is a good idea to attempt to change the culture in football. Punishments for several pretty shitty things are too lax, so players aren’t really disincentivized from doing them. This could help.
But, of course, it depends on good implementation…
Just enforce the rules we have now consistently. Lets work out whats working by following the rules first?
but those rules dont appropriately punish thats the issue.
cynical fouling exists because the trade off is worth it, its like a fine to a rich person.
we need to stamp out tactical fouls and cynical fouls, weve just grown to accept them.
Cynical fouls don’t always earn cards. Like the examples.
Book them every time, and it stops.
They do if they were applied. Yellow card. Do it twice, you’re off the field. Do it once and it’s seriously denying an opportunity red card.
Like you said, we’ve grown to accept them - THATS the problem.
Those rules are not enough when players gladly take the punishment of receiving a yellow instead of conceding a goal. It’s not that “they don’t get booked 100% of the time”. That’s the entire point. If they 100% get booked, it’s still worth it.
Awful idea that only adds more of a grey area between the red and yellow card. Can’t help but think that teams against city will also likely be likely to receive more of these decisions as to add to more corruption.
what corruption you weirdo?
if anything city will get punished more as the classic rodri pull back will be a 10 min sinbin
Ffs.
tf is a 10 minute sin bin? are they sitting out for 10 minutes and the opposing team has a bit of a power play like hockey? or is it like they have 10 minutes where if they commit another foul they will be sent off? i don’t watch rugby enough to follow
edit: so it’s like a hickey power play. this is dumb. stop changing the game
I don’t see what the point of this is, we already have a punishment for cynical fouls and if you’re team does it repeatedly it should be a red card eventually. All I see this doing is trans forfeiting a player for ten minutes to stop breaks late in the game.
I mean, it beats just throwing yourself on the ground holding your head for 10 minutes at least, but otherwise I agree it’s just kicking the problem further down the road.
we already have a punishment for cynical fouls
but we dont though do we otherwise we would not see them happen to any level they happen today.
As opposed to players stopping breaks late in a game and getting a lesser punishment, which is the current rule.
Excellent news, hope it works - dissent against refs is becoming appalling and tactical fouling is cheating and needs to be punished properly
So it’s hockey now is it?
This reads like an April fools headline ffs.
A chance for more ‘subjective’ and inconsistent calls.
Great. I look forward to watching teams grind play to an absolute standstill until their man is back on.