- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
You must log in or register to comment.
It’s a walking stick not a standing stick, Rohidiot.
The “quiver of little walking sticks” got me.
Wow. That elf lady is super cute.
It houses the flame of Anor! Thirty rounds of it!
100 rounds if you buy a Drum of Holding.
I’ve always taken it that the guard knew Gandalf’s staff was a weapon, but also knew his king was compromised and Gandalf was there to help. There was enough plausible deniability to let the staff through.
Yes, there’s definitely a bit of wink wink, nudge nudge going on
Huh, I never thought to read the scene that way.
“Speak friend and enter!”
“Here’s my NRA membership card.”
Watcher in the Water: “MAGA!”
Did Gandalf even need a staff? I figured a maiar didn’t need magic items.
LotR magic is interesting. Sauron bred all kinds of monsters essentially “hacking the system” to produce something in a world where no one but Illuvatar can create life, and Melkor got around the whole life/sentience thing by convincing lesser spirits to inhabit this creations. Balrogs, werewolves, etc.
Other creations Melkor imbued with his own vast power, essentially spreading his “divine fire” out amongst his thralls, and thereby diminishing himself. Sauron eventually does the same, in creating the One Ring.
So, when Gandalf became Gandalf, his power to affect things was explicitly limited. , The basic difference between The Istari and Sauron: they did not seek to usurp their position in ‘the song of Illuvatar’. In fact the five Istari (Gandalf, Saruman, Radagast and the other unnamed two) were maiar spirits that had until that point stayed out of Arda (Earth) and all its shenanigans on purpose!
So, the staff served as a badge of office mostly. And thought it never stated, it’s kind of implied that some of their power is imbued within it. This is why Gandalf looks totally different when he comes back as the White, he took Saruman’s job as the head of the order, and had some more of his power unlocked as a result. The main strength of the Istari was their wisdom, knowing how the world worked and to a point, how “the song” was supposed to go. They were trusted to do the job (of taking down Sauron) because they wouldn’t use their knowledge and power to ‘hack the system’.
IMHO, Gandalf needed his staff not as a conduit of power here, but as an emblem of his station: He had to show Grima that his boss had just been fired.
Ah that makes sense. The staff being emblematic of the Valar’s trust in Gandalf and his authority. It had just seemed like he needed it (in the movies, so maybe not canon) to push Saruman out of Theoden.
So, when Gandalf became Gandalf, his power to affect things was explicitly limited.
I thought it was just that they promised not to use more than a small fraction of their power to influence men, and then only to guide them and not to rule. I had thought the implication was that Gandalf was perfectly fine with using his full power as long as he was opposing a dire threat beyond mortals and could match it’s power. Like how he went toe-to-toe with the Balrog of Moria: a corrupted Maiar itself. And that Saruman was effectively using all the power he had as a Maiar to corrupt, mutate, influence, and rule. Explicitly against what he promised to do as an istari.
Exactly, yes! They were self-limited, and the valar trusted them to be so, which is why Saruman turning evil caught Gandalf super off guard!
We know the names of the Blue Wizards, they’re Alatar and Pallando. Or at least that’s what Tolkien called them in The Unfinished Tales, which admittedly aren’t particularly worthy of being considered “canon.”
Looked like he did. He was facing a more powerful wizard, one who had beaten him before, and one that had Sauron’s aid.
