OP about to open a whole can of worms with this one… 🤣

4, Amanda Seyfried always. Lindsay Logan was hot back them and Rachel McAdams is super cute, specially on the About Time years. But Amanda has something about her, and her eyes you get lost in them.

Man Lindsay Lohan was so hot, amazing legs back then.

Shame.

4

back then 3, now 1

I was a huge mark for Lindsay back then. We’re about the same age. However, that didn’t last long due to her fall. Rachel McAdams was a long time favorite, so I’ll go with her.

3 is the cutest. But I’ll take no 4 because I’m not going for cute.