• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    -22 months ago

    Keep in mind both of these maps are grossly misleading. Or at least one is being presented in a misleading way.

    One is just coloring an entire county the way the majority voted. This is why those huge (land) counties are all red, because at least 1 more person in it votes for trump than Biden (presumably, I don’t know what the map is actually based on but it’s a safe bet). So that’s why “the sand” is regularly colored red. Although saying noone lives these is misleading.

    Which leads me to the second map is probably a noble effort to show some population scale, by reducing all of the counties to a circle the relative size of their population, but it’s being misrepresented here as if that’s where all of the people in those counties live, which is certainly false. Just look at the center of the country, it’s basically a grid of small dots. Do people honestly think the population is distributed like that?

    The most frustrating thing about this is everyone in this thread is complaining about how Republicans are too stupid to understand why the map is colored the way it is…while being absolutely fooled as to why the other map is the way it is.

    • OptionalOP
      link
      fedilink
      12 months ago

      The most frustrating thing about this is everyone in this thread is complaining about how Republicans are too stupid to understand why the map is colored the way it is…while being absolutely fooled as to why the other map is the way it is.

      Fwiw I don’t think anyone’s “fooled” by the first map. Or (again, imo) that all republiQans are too stupid to understand why sand doesn’t vote.

      I do think the first map is regularly used as a right-wing talking point by individuals and corporate news to “explain” how republiQans must be winning elections, and that explanation is false. Presumably many of the individuals and all corporate news organizations know that. Which is why it’s just straight-up propaganda.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        12 months ago

        My point is that the second map, at least the way it is being framed in this meme, is equally misleading.

        What it is presumably showing is dot in the middle of each county (although clearly not in middle for places like the NE that are being pushed apart, but I think it’s true for like kansas/nebraska) that is scaled relative to the population of that county. It’s not necessarily where the people in that county live.

        I get that Republicans use the former map to deceive and spread propaganda. What I’m pointing out is that is exactly what is happening with the way the second map is being framed in this meme. It’s pure absurdity for people to fall hook, line, and sinker for it. . .while shitting on the intelligence of people who fell hook, line, and sinker for another map being presented in a misleading way.

        • OptionalOP
          link
          fedilink
          12 months ago

          Oh right - well, again fwiw, I doubt people are lead to believe that midwest populations are laid out in perfect order like that.

          Hm. That said, most midwest towns are laid out in some kind of grid. But that’s more about transportation than politics.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      02 months ago

      Possibly because unless you have an eight figure trust fund the GOP doesn’t help you, so if you vote Republican you are stupid?

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        02 months ago

        Apparently, hating dumb Republicans doesn’t preclude you from being dumb yourself. Imagine that

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            22 months ago

            It’s funny because my point was based off of what you actually said, your’s was just a mindless childish insult… ironically accusing me of making childish retorts.

            It’s funny how much you see what you hate about yourself in other people.