I’ve thought about tube vs tubeless with regular riding, like commuting, and have a slightly different conclusion. For the record, I’m 100% tubed and still haven’t managed to give away sealant that I got for free.
Tubeless has two nice commuting/regular-riding benefits. First is when there are frequent encounters small punctures, like thorns or steel wire. The maintenance time benefit of tubes disappears quickly in this case. Minor punctures with tubes can be mitigated with puncture resistant tires or liners, but that compromises ride quality and speed.
Second, every moment of your time isn’t created equal. Time when traveling is not as fungible as maintenance time. I can schedule tubeless maintenance. I cannot schedule when I get a puncture. Tubeless is zero delay or just a quick pump-up compared to patching a tube. Even catastrophic punctures are a wash; both setups need a new tube.
What setup to use really does come down to “it depends.” Are you always cutting it close to get to where you need to go, but are good with routines? Consider fast tires in a tubeless setup. Do you struggle to maintain your bike or are always early to your destination? Marathon Plus tires with butyl tubes would be a solid choice.
As for me? I only carry patches for most of my rides. It works on every one of my bikes and I’m not usually riding somewhere with less than 15 minutes of buffer time. Although it does suck to patch a tube when riding at night. That’s a suck I’m willing to take.
I’ve thought about tube vs tubeless with regular riding, like commuting, and have a slightly different conclusion. For the record, I’m 100% tubed and still haven’t managed to give away sealant that I got for free.
Tubeless has two nice commuting/regular-riding benefits. First is when there are frequent encounters small punctures, like thorns or steel wire. The maintenance time benefit of tubes disappears quickly in this case. Minor punctures with tubes can be mitigated with puncture resistant tires or liners, but that compromises ride quality and speed.
Second, every moment of your time isn’t created equal. Time when traveling is not as fungible as maintenance time. I can schedule tubeless maintenance. I cannot schedule when I get a puncture. Tubeless is zero delay or just a quick pump-up compared to patching a tube. Even catastrophic punctures are a wash; both setups need a new tube.
What setup to use really does come down to “it depends.” Are you always cutting it close to get to where you need to go, but are good with routines? Consider fast tires in a tubeless setup. Do you struggle to maintain your bike or are always early to your destination? Marathon Plus tires with butyl tubes would be a solid choice.
As for me? I only carry patches for most of my rides. It works on every one of my bikes and I’m not usually riding somewhere with less than 15 minutes of buffer time. Although it does suck to patch a tube when riding at night. That’s a suck I’m willing to take.
I did not like liners but I found puncture resistant worked well enough that I have not gone tubeless.