First police investigation of Supernova festival also found Israeli forces responsible for some deaths.

First police investigation of Supernova festival also found Israeli forces responsible for some deaths.

  • Ooops
    10•8 months ago

    And nobody said that Hamas terror acts were not an atrocity. What was instead criticised is the fact that IDF soldiers also taking their part in killing civilians there is completely and pointedly ignored.

    Which you then justify with some bullshit of how it would not have happened without the Hama’s attack in the first place.

    So my point stands: If you think that soldiers indiscriminately shooting civilians is to blame solely on Hamas, then police shooting civilians while trying to stop a robbing is to be blamed solely on the robber, too.

      • Ooops
        0•8 months ago

        There are reports that IDF members were there, too. Shooting back amid civilians. It was probably chaotic and nobody actually knows who was shot by whom, because Israel is refusing to even investigate. In fact they also refuse to make public how many IDF members were there and how many died or how many Hamas members died. They only categorically tell us a total number, implying all dead were peaceful civilians killed by Hamas.

        • @[email protected]
          1•8 months ago

          (I’m sorry if this appears multiple times. My lemmy client is giving me errors as I try to save this comment)

          Active IDF members, or just citizens armed and trained from their days as active IDF?

          You say they were shooting back from amid civilians. That’s not them participating in the massacre at all. That’s them defending the civilians. The best way to suppress gunfire coming into a group of people is to send gunfire back at the source.

          Shooting a gun requires aiming, aiming requires looking, and looking requires exposing your head. This is why you can suppress gunfire by firing in its direction. The person has to choose between continuing to fire at you, and protecting their own head.

          I say head because that’s basically what you need to expose in order to fire, if the rest of you is in cover. If the attackers aren’t in cover then firing back at them is even more effective because unless they stop firing and get to cover their entire body is in danger.

          So firing back is totally legit behavior if that’s all they did.

          Do you have any reports of IDF firing on other festival attendees?

    • @[email protected]English
      -2•8 months ago

      I doubt very much that it is being ignored by the families of those involved. I highly doubt that Israel will be honest regarding the facts. But again there is a huge difference between blue on blue events and deliberate murders. Or are you suggesting Israel killed civilians deliberately also?