Hi, I was looking at private CAs since I don’t want to pay for a domain to use in my homelab.

What is everyone using for their private CA? I’ve been looking at plain OpenSSL with some automation scripts but would like more ideas. Also, if you have multiple reverse-proxy instances, how do you distribute domain-specific signed certificates to them? I’m not planning to use a wildcard, and would like to rotate certificates often.

Thanks!

Edit: thank you for everyone who commented! I would like to say that I recognise the technical difficulty in getting such a setup working compared to a simple certbot setup to Let’s Encrypt, but it’s a personal choice that I have made.

  • @[email protected]English
    1•7 months ago

    Okay that’s fair but if your only concern is about “I do not want any public CA to know the domains and subdomains I use” you get around that.

    Let’s Encrypt now allows for wildcard so you can probably do something like *.network.example.org and have an SSL certificate that will cover any subdomain under network.example.org (eg. host1.network.example.org). Or even better, get a wildcard like *.example.org and you’ll be done for everything.

    I’m just suggesting this alternative because it would make your life way easier and potentially more secure without actually revealing internal subdomains to the CA.

    Another option is to just issue certificates without a CA and accept them one at the time on each device. This won’t expose you to a possibly stolen CA PK and you’ll get notified if previously the accepted certificate of some host changes.

    openssl req -x509 -nodes -newkey rsa:2048 \
-subj "/CN=$DOMAIN_BASE/O=$ORG_NAME/OU=$ORG_UNIT_NAME/C=$COUNTRY" \
-keyout $DOMAIN_BASE.key -out $DOMAIN_BASE.crt -days $OPT_days "${ALT_NAMES[@]}"
    • @[email protected]OPEnglish
      2•7 months ago

      My apologies, I didn’t word my concerns properly in the moment. I would like to run a private CA simply because I do not want to use a public domain for my internal network. It makes me deeply uncomfortable to use a public domain and get public certificates for something inherently so private (it’s more philosophical than technical, although I suppose that’s where a lot of opinionated technical decisions come from anyway). Your solution is elegant and simple, but I really do want to do it completely internally, and move towards zero trust security practices as I do. Basically, I want to start training myself on the security side of SRE in my lab, running services which matter to me and working like the more paranoid SRE teams in corporations work…I know this sounds like fantasy, and my needs might change going forward, but I’m also hoping to learn a lot from this and hopefully make this as robust as I can. Having a good security posture makes me feel warm inside :)

      • @[email protected]English
        2•7 months ago

        It makes me deeply uncomfortable to use a public domain and get public certificates for something inherently so private

        You can obviously run your own CA, great exercise but why? What really makes you that uncomfortable? Once you go with the wildcard nobody will know about your internal hosts or whatever. Even if the domain is taken down, you’re offline or wtv your local DNS server will still be able to serve replies to those internal subdomains. You don’t need to publish those subdomains (A records) in a public DNS server, just on your own internal DNS server.

        I guess if you rally want to take the CA route those tools I provided before are the best option. Simply issuing a certificate (without a CA) and allowing it on a browser might also work for you - less risks of stolen PK as described.

        I hope the links and tips helped you in some way.