• Emma <MarmadileManteater>
    27•1 year ago

    I like pixelfed. I have a pixelfed account, and feature-wise, I see how it could replace someone’s use of instagram, but personally, I was never on instagram for its features. I was on instagram because I made friends in real life who I couldn’t keep in touch with in absolutely any other way. Meanwhile, I am on pixelfed because I like the idea of a federated social media platform based around images, but I have zero connections on that platform.

    I posted to it twice. Then, I realized that, unless I could convince the people that I knew on instagram to join pixelfed, it would never be the same experience, so I stopped. I would just rather post pictures to my mastodon account which has more reach than my pixelfed. The concept of an image based social media platform is less compelling when you don’t know anyone there, and this is what Meta is banking on.

    Sure, there are alternatives to Instagram that are better, but all of my IRL friends & family are on Meta platforms already and don’t want to leave 🤷‍♀️, so what’s the point? Even if I manage to convince someone that it is important, they might bail at some point because they can’t convince the people they know from instagram to join the alternative, and that’s how it is all down the line: friction, friction, friction.

    • @[email protected]
      8•1 year ago

      I think you’re spot on. I use Instagram for one niche sport I do, hydrofoil surfing. Everyone who foils is on there, and as a result the development speed of this 5-year-old sport is incredible. Someone in Australia invents a new maneuver, posts a video of it, and a few hours later while they’re sleeping people in America are trying it out.

      None of that is happening on pixelfed. I tried it out too, and, meh. There’s just nothing interesting on there, and it’s too complicated to explain to non techies. So there’s a huge barrier to entry and no compelling reason to surmount it. Heck, I have an advanced degree in informatics and I barely made it over the choose an instance wall. My perma-stoned surfing buddies don’t stand a chance.

    • @[email protected]
      8•1 year ago

      Here’s a good reason. Since Facebook likes to spy on you, I put Instagram on my work profile on Android, effectively sandboxing it. I’d had the account for several years at this point. Just the other day, it told me that my account had been flagged for violating the rules and trying to access data I wasn’t supposed to have access to. It asked me to upload an image of myself with a code written on a piece of paper to prove I wasn’t a bot, and they still deleted my profile and said I was acting as a bot and that I could not appeal the decision or talk to a human about it.

      I agree it’s a bit of a pain to get people to join these nerd apps, but man, it beats dealing with non-interactive bot/algorithm, punishing you for fighting back against having your information stolen.