• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    95 months ago

    I don’t really care about US politics, but I find data quite interesting. Now I would not say this is outright false, but highly misleading. A quick search led me to this csv of to whom minors were released: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nytimes/hhs-child-migrant-data/main/data.csv Running a quick script on my phone, 41.7% of the 553321 children were released to a parent, and further 46.7% to a blood relative (brother/sister, aunt/uncle, grandma/pa). So only 64340 were in the other category, which includes family friends, other distant relatives and unrelated sponsors.

    Now I will not go into if 64 thousand children is “good enough”, or doubt that many of them work. But it is not a problem exclusive to unacompanied minors. I would think that if parents force their children to work, that is regardless of if they came alone or with their parents.

    I would say the tweet is highly missleading, because it makes it seem as if there are 400 thousand abandoned migrant children working in the US.

    An other fact to consider, is that in 1860 the US population was 34 millions while it currently sits at 335 million. So comparassions of absolute numbers in a historical context are usually not a good idea.

    • @OnlyTakesLsOP
      link
      -55 months ago

      Every country seperates arrested minors from arrested adults. How is that any different?

      • Melllvar
        link
        fedilink
        65 months ago

        Because in this case the separations were not a side effect of an otherwise legitimate policy, but were intentionally designed to deter people of particular racial and ethnic backgrounds from seeking asylum.

        That amounts to a crime against humanity.

        • @MomoTimeToDie
          link
          -35 months ago

          Yes, anything sounds worse when you just make up insane lies about it

              • Melllvar
                link
                fedilink
                4
                edit-2
                5 months ago

                Declaring asylum seekers to be criminals without hearing their asylum claim is a contributing factor to my characterizing Trump’s separation policy as crime against humanity.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -45 months ago

                  I didn’t see anything in your source that indicates asylum seekers were deemed criminals without hearing their asylum claim.

                • ThrowawayM
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -65 months ago

                  Illegally immigrating is a crime, regardless if they claim asylum after they get caught.