I’m wondering if it isn’t better to just whitelist cookies for the sites I need to log into and not bother with a password manager extension (keepasxc or bitwarden). I try to keep the number of extensions in my browser to a minimum to lower the attack surface. And why involve one more entity in the password story? Are there any problems with using the (1st party) cookies of sites I have signed up to and use to keep me signed in?
well, off i understand you correctly, you want to just stay logged in and never bother with the password in your device? That comes with a heap of problems:
- what if someone else gains access to your device, they’d have instant access to all your accounts
- what if your device died? If you don’t know the passwords you can never log in on anything else.
- if you whitelist cookies those sites could track you across other sites, thus INCREASING your attack surface
Thanks for your response. Points 1 and 2 would be the same if I used an in browser password manager. I backup all passwords on my desktop manager and my laptop is pretty hard to break into. For point 3, do 1st party cookies track people? I thought they were mostly benign and for site settings.
-
No. Your desktop password manager is encrypted with a strong passphrase that locks when you’re computer locks. (Right?) They’d have to snatch your gear mid-session. Cookies are not safe, and cookie hijacks are a pretty common exploit. Cookies are for convenience, not security. Retaining authentication cookies is a very big security hole that we all do, and it’s why banks don’t let you re-auth on a previous session cookie.
-
“Pretty hard to break into” is the kind of phrase that keeps infosec people up at night. It’s the kind of phrase that reads to me as “full of vulnerabilities so I can easily break in.” You probably want to read up on your security practices.
-
Yes. First party cookies can be just as nefarious in addition to the technical requirements. Cookie managers are more relaxed about first party because we assume you’re on that site for a reason, not because the cookies aren’t a risk.
3a. Never assume that something supposed to be “mostly benign” isn’t currently being exploited for bad reasons.
To your OP, It’s actually not a terrible idea to uninstall the PW manager browser extension. It’s one more layer of isolation from the browser. You just lose the convenience of autofill.
But definitely rely on the PW manager for session security and not cookies.
Edit: a couple edits.
Thanks, I will be deleting all cookies and using my desktop keepassxc.
You really don’t need to be that paranoid for personal stuff. Use a cookie manager extension like NoCookie, NoScript, uBlock Origin, and isolate with Firefox Containers.
The idea of an “attack surface” from extensions is valid enough, but you can improve your overall security posture with more good extensions thanv trying to manually maintain everything yourself.
-
in that case i install 2 browsers. One that they use for the sites they need to login (with 3rd party cookies disabled), another with higher security preferences and blockers for general browsing
You can use Firefox container that compartmentalize websites (that you chose)
i can. They don’t.
What? I didn’t get your message
it’s a solution i use for other people who ask for some privacy but don’t want to spend time learning about it. I say: here, use this with your “paperwork”, personal connections &c and use this for all the rest of the internets
