• dual_sport_dork 🐧🗡️@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    7 months ago

    Excellent writeup. I’m stoked to see a decent and reasonably inexpensive offering that can use removable commodity cells. As you observed, the recent fixation seems to be to make “ultralight” bullshit with internal battery packs that are not user replaceable. The worst part is, the ultralight hiking community insists on lapping these things up and you’ll get ridiculed if you mention wanting a light with swappable cells. “Just carry a power bank and recharge it!”

    The problem is twofold. First, there are nontrivial losses involved when you charge off of a powerbank, so you have to carry around extra size and weight in mAh just to break even on run time. Plus the ability to slap in a commodity primary cell in an emergency is helpful, or you can just carry 1-2 extra cells with you if you know your excursion is going to be long enough to warrant it. And when the internal battery inevitably wears out you can easily buy and install another one. But I’m sure Petzl or Black Diamond or whoever would much rather you buy an entire new light, instead.

    At present I’m carrying a yum-cha brandless 18650 headlamp which works well enough for me, but I may have to investigate one of these instead. My current headlamp has been reliable (a lot moreso than both Black Diamond headlamps I had before it which mysteriously conked out like clockwork after about a year for no identifiable reason) but it doesn’t have any kind of mode memory nor does it have a control lockout. When it’s bouncing around in my pack during the day I stick the battery in it backwards. My usual EDC light is a Lumintop Tool 2.0 which can use a 14500 cell, so being able to use the same batteries will be nice. Although it’s not like I don’t have approximately 4.3 million spare 18650’s lying around anyway, which is why I bought a cheap 18650 light to begin with.

    • Zak Reviews@social.goodanser.comOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      7 months ago

      @dual_sport_dork I definitely have trouble relating to the ultralight crowd. I’d be more inclined to take an 18650 headlamp and an 18650 powerbank so I could swap cells between them than to recharge a headlamp from a powerbank.

      • dual_sport_dork 🐧🗡️@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        7 months ago

        There is such a thing as “stupid light.” Where that line is drawn varies to some extent from person to person, but ye gods forbid you draw it elsewhere than where the hivemind does or you’ll be relentlessly attacked.

        Even before leaving reddit entirely I had to unsub from /ultralight because those guys had devolved into just being flat-out insane. Plus, it was the same conversation over and over again. Once you have your loadout all dialed in the way you like it there’s not much left to talk about other than nitpicking other people’s gear choices and generalized circlejerking. I used to enjoy researching and shopping for and, yes, buying new camping gear. But at this point in my life I really don’t need yet another tent, sleeping bag, backpack, or inflatable pad. I’ve learned all the hard lessons and I have everything the way I want it. (Not that this has stopped me from continuing to buy knives and flashlights en masse. That’s different, obviously! I mean, duh.) You’re better off actually going out and using your stuff versus sitting at home obsessing over the latest headlamp with a battery too small, titanium spork that’s too short to reach the bottom of the bowl, or tent made out of the next ephemeral fabric that’ll disintegrate on contact with pine needles but is 0.002% lighter per square yard.

        Tl;dr: I’m all for lugging less weight around if you don’t need to, but not at the expense of my equipment no longer being capable of doing its job.

        • Zak Reviews@social.goodanser.comOP
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          7 months ago

          @dual_sport_dork I think something similar happens any time people hyper-focus on a single attribute of their gear. The brightest headlamp is as unlikely to be a community favorite as the lightest because maximizing any one attribute has costs to others.

          It’s just an odd quirk that a community sprang up around minimizing weight as its core principle. “I want a good X that’s lightweight” makes more sense to me than “I want a lightweight X that’s good”.