• SorteKanin@feddit.dkEnglish
    294·
    6 months ago

    I never understood the idea behind these kind of automatic slur filters.

    First of all, why even allow the comment at all? Why not just remove the whole thing? Censoring just the slur doesn’t help that much and can just be confusing.

    Secondly, by filtering the slur like this, it’s less likely that the person posting the slur would be reported and thus no moderator sees the fact that someone posted slurs (unless slur-filtered comments are auto-reported; are they? I don’t know). That’s the opposite of what you want! If you have slurs that should be disallowed, get people to report those that post them and tell people not to do it or ban them if they keep doing it.

    When it’s filtered like this and nobody reports the comment, the user posting the slur will probably just continue doing it.

    And of course in addition to all the above, there’s the problem that it doesn’t take into account the context at all, which is what leads to the image of this post.

    • rtxn@lemmy.worldEnglish
      182·
      6 months ago

      Good ol’ ScunthorpeM181. I was once banned from a school project on historical fiction and sent to the principal for writing “'ass” in one of the files. It was about Assassin’s Creed. I was very close to calling that system removed, especially because it wasn’t even English.

    • DannyBoyEnglish
      64·
      6 months ago

      You’d never get it there if you don’t retard the timing on the fire truck’s motor.

  • Peter1986C@lemmings.worldEnglish
    6·
    6 months ago

    AFAIK lemmy.ml is the only instance that still has the filter on. When federation was not enabled yet and there practically were only two (!) instances up and running, people on Lemmy were already pointing out that things like posted by OP would happen. 😆

    Edit: I think however, that this case was mostly in jest and on purpose.