EDIT: Winner = You and I (Must Die) by House of Mammoth!

Vote below by indicating your choice for your soap!

PS: Nearly managed to list the soaps (counter-) alphabetically 🙄

  • PorkButtsNTaters666@sub.wetshaving.socialOP
    4·
    9 days ago

    We have a winner: You and I (Must Die) by House of Mammoth! ~Halloween and All Saints Day may have helped prepare the terrain for this one…~

    Anyways: Congratulations to @[email protected], who is on a run with his second consecutive win – will he be able to secure the hat-trick?

    Here are the results of the wetshaving jury:

    DJ SN DW SH GCG NDG Total
    AYLM Ishtar 6 9 5 7 4 31
    BM Brew Ha-Ha 2 4 9 7 22
    BM Latha Taiga 7 2 3 5 17
    CB Reflection 1 7 4 10 8 9 39
    CF Pine Tar 4 3 8 15
    GN Cosecha Catalana 8 6 2 10 26
    HM You & I 9 8 6 8 3 10 44
    J2J Masala Connection 5 1 7 9 8 30
    J2J Noir 10 10 10 9 2 41
    SS Britannia 3 5 1 6 15

    @[email protected] – could you reach out to Walden and give him your address?

    • DaveWave94@sub.wetshaving.social
      2·
      9 days ago

      First off, thanks for organising these every time. Your efforts have my utmost respect and none of what follows is meant to be a personal critique. It’s all meant in good faith.

      I have to issue a few minor complaints:

      • we should wait until every member who wants to participate has voted (walden doesn’t mind this time, but I imagine it might be very disappointing if he indeed did want to vote); alternatively have a clear deadline to do so
      • we probably should have a rule in place what happens when someone doesn’t rank every soap. We had more than ever before this time, so I see how some people couldn’t be bothered - but I personally think they deserve at least some token vote points
      • likewise, we might need to limit nominations to one soap per member. As you said, there’s always next month to suggest another one.

      These are just minor issues, but I guess like every club we need to follow at least a bare minimum of rules. BVWSC has been really great so far and I find it charming how open and inviting our Lemmy community is.

      Perhaps those are only personal issues though; I am of course open to discussion with other members and receptive for constructive feedback. Cheers & have a nice evening ✌🏻

      • PorkButtsNTaters666@sub.wetshaving.socialOP
        3·
        9 days ago

        Yeah, these are valid complaints.

        Next time, I will announce before how much time ther is or voting, maybe something like 48 h?

        Also, I’ll check how different ways of counting votes interact with partial votes.

        I will put up a thread for discussion soon.

        • DaveWave94@sub.wetshaving.social
          3·
          9 days ago

          Thanks!

          I personally think 48 hours would be enough for everyone to make their choice in a timely manner.

          Maybe something like 2 token points for every unranked soap would be okay. I think this wouldn’t mess with the general voting consensus, of course depending on how many soaps are suggested.

          That’s a great idea with a discussion thread! I am sure we’d find a good consensus based on democratic decision making. Thanks again for coming up with the idea of BVWSC 👍🏻