This is a bit of an experiment. Someone was asking me to post in a different way and I was not wild about it but im sorta wondering how a link directly the the comic image itself will come up.
This is a bit of an experiment. Someone was asking me to post in a different way and I was not wild about it but im sorta wondering how a link directly the the comic image itself will come up.
no I was doing that but it was not showing the picture in feeds and someone liked that. I mean its not hard to go from the picture link to the main page. its gonna be hard to please everyone.
Why not do both?
Sorry if this comes across as me picking on anything you are doing - you asked how it’s working so I am commenting more freely with my thoughts here than I otherwise would have.
The picture shows the content without someone needing to click, but the link provides attribution for things where that matters more - like not memes but comics in particular, or artwork that people could purchase.
Here’s an example where I recently did both: https://piefed.social/post/370988#comment_3945627. Do as you please ofc, I just offered in case it might help.
I get it now but this goes back to why I did not want to do the original suggestion of downloading and uploading the file. I really just want to copy the url and put it in or do something with that few of clicks and no screwing around with formatting for appearance and url to appear seperate and such.
You can do whatever you want.
I suppose if you are saying that you will only ever do one or the other, then I would agree with you then that the link is the more valuable of the two.
Though personally I do feel that there is value also in showing the preview immediately without having to first click - like a Rick Roll scenario, the recipient doesn’t know yet whether they want to follow down that rabbit hole.
But I would most definitely not have used all this many words on my own initiative, I’m just trying to answer your question: personally, I choose to do both, in situations where it is not my OC but I want to share in the most appropriate manner possible. In an ideal world the software itself could show the image and the attribution both just by giving it the URL, but Lemmy it seems is not that advanced (although PieFed will do so, even for YouTube videos it shows them in an embedded player:-D, so there is hope for the future event if not much for today:-). And then for both I suppose the rules differ for posts vs. comments.