I think I’m going with…

1. DS1 Zweihander (in later games this is Greatsword)

• the best UGS moveset

2. Washing Pole (Nagakiba in ER)

• let’s be honest it’s because of FF7, but it’s dope af

3. Moonlight Greatsword (all iterations, Bloodborne is probably the best one though)

• ah you were here at my side all along

4. Chikage (moveset is unique to Bloodborne)

• the draw slash tranform move made this really unique and fun

5. Demon Scar (ds3)

• a unique weapon in this game, like wielding a sword made of Pyromancy