csm10495/commit-ment
github.com
How many commits can Github handle? Contribute to csm10495/commit-ment development by creating an account on GitHub.

I decided to see how many commits GitHub (and git) could take before acting kind of wonky. At ~19 million commits (and counting) to master: it’s wonky.

The GitHub API has periodic issues merging/creating PRs. (I use PRs since that is more reliable than keeping a local master up to date via pulling at this point).

GitHub reports… infinity infinity commits. Doing a full clone from GitHub Actions is taking around 2 hours.

Using:

git pull origin master

to update my local master hangs for a while before even printing anything.

If anyone has seen a public GitHub repo with more commits to its main branch, let me know.

If anyone wants to see how slow wonky git acts at this scale, feel free to clone.

Edit: Update to this post is: https://sh.itjust.works/post/672069

  • JimEnglish
    12•11 months ago

    Some people just want to see the world burn. Haha.

      • @[email protected]English
        6•11 months ago

        I love it.

        These are the types of people to find something “Huh, that’s a weird reaction”

    • @csm10495OPEnglish
      6•11 months ago

      Part of me wants to try to look into the git cli to try to see why some of the hangs happen. I don’t think any sort of hang with no output (at least with -v) should happen normally.

      Who knows if I’ll get to that point.

      Otherwise I’ll let it just keep committing.

  • @[email protected]English
    4•11 months ago

    I wonder if the size of the commits also plays a role.
    The latests commits are just an index being incremented, it’d be interesting to update the script to replace and commit lorem impsum text (maybe two or three paragraphs would be a good base)

  • KogasaEnglish
    1•11 months ago

    Infinity commits is interesting. Do you think it’s caused by GitHub trying to count commits and timing out?

    • @csm10495OPEnglish
      3•11 months ago

      At this point I think so. Even the API (v3 or graphql) can’t get me a commit count anymore. It usually gives something like a 503 with a reference id to give support.

      Needless to say, I don’t think its worth bugging support about it :P

      • @[email protected]English
        1•11 months ago

        It might be worth it. Not sure their systems have been stressed in this way before and they might want some engineers to look at it. It could lead to some more efficencies in smaller repos. Or it could lead to nothing. Might be worth contacting them to see. Even if you ultimately don’t care about this repo.

        • @csm10495OPEnglish
          1•11 months ago

          Fair enough. I created a thread on the support forum. Since I don’t have a paid account, I can’t contact support directly.