• veaviticus@lemmy.one
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    1 year ago

    Yes. If you run the server, then you are the source of truth of that community. All other servers that federate your community query your server to access the community and show it to their users.

    So if you run a server and a community explodes there, you might only have 500 users on your instance, but you might have 50k users reading that community and interacting with it from other Lemmy instances, thus your server needs to scale to 50k users worth.

    And ever more essential, your server is the source of truth of that community. So if your server is hacked or corrupted or deleted, that community is gone. Other instances don’t mirror it (except for temporary caching), so the Lemmy network essentially is a trust network of other people maintaining servers long term (and each inventing a monetary system to pay for it). I still think the network might be better than a centralized system like reddit, but it definitely has a lot of growing and policies that need to be sorted out very soon

    • TheAmorphous@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      So are these other servers just routing requests from their users to your server’s community? Or are they actually copying everything over every so often (caching) and serving up the requests themselves? How real time is it, I guess is what I’m asking?

      • veaviticus@lemmy.one
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        1 year ago

        Yeah, apparently I was wrong about this (still learning lemmy and fediverse stuff…). Text content of posts and comments are “synced” to your server and stored in your database there. Then future requests for that content are served from your instance. So its not as bad as I thought it was (the network load should be lower since you aren’t acting as entirely a proxy, more like a cache), but database bloat will be a huge problem (its already a big problem in other federated things like mastodon and matrix, where every server ends up saving everything they want into their own database).

        I’m not sure what happens when the original server goes down, does the federated servers discard that data? Or do we each maintain a forever copy until we want to get rid of it ourselves? There’s also some notes I’ve seen about how servers only incrementally cache federated content (only posts and comments that are viewed by someone are fetched, and new comments may not be fetched until someone wants to see it)… so not everybody has a “pure and full” copy of posts necessarily.

        But overall I wonder how all the various sysadmins hosting these lemmy instances will deal with the expotential growth they’re going to see, or if smaller instances will start defederating to save on hardware costs (no reason for my tiny instance that only talks about blue shiny rocks to federate with lemmy.world and store all that content)

      • aard@kyu.de
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        Information about post changes on the originating instance come in pretty much in real time, and get saved in the local database.

        If the local instance is configured with pictrs support images are also cached locally.