• 6 Posts
  • 3.2K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 15th, 2023

help-circle

  • Most of us here are leftists of some shade, we roughly agree on theory. The tankie problem is one of implementation. It’s delusional either in its estimation of the percentage of people willing and able to join the movement, or in its faith that the vanguard state totally won’t turn into a dictatorship this time. I think most people here could be convinced to join the movement they’re pushing if the movement was supported by a practical plan of implementation. Right now it’s supported either by dreams and wishes, or 90+% of the population being shipped to the gulags










  • My grandad, a Trump voter, has several times in the past talked about how golf is like life: it doesn’t matter if the sun was in your eyes, or a dog barked in the middle of your swing, or a sudden breeze pushed your drive off target, all that matters at the end of the day is the number you put in that little box, no excuses. The irony is lost on him.




  • She is an immigrant and not particularly well informed politically. I went on to explain the predictable cycle of Republican presidents leading to market crashes which the wealthy use to buy up assets for cheap, and indicated to Project 2025 which was published well in advance of the election. She seemed to respond as if I had given her valid information that she lacked before (which wasn’t really the case, we’d talked about this well before November). But she didn’t really have any pushback or response, she mostly seemed quiet and contemplative.




  • Hurts the petit bourgeoisie, which is the only ones the working class see

    So billionaires will be way better off, politicians will be fine, the working class is doomed, rights will be stripped away from vulnerable minorities, but that’s fine because small business owners will also be hurt? I just question the rationale of that strategy. It is literally a 4chan NEET’s “screw everyone” plot.

    Also, because Trump is a vengeful narcissist, you can bet that certain sections of the liberal elite are going to get a coating.

    This seems like burning down your whole neighborhood to get back at the guy down the street.



  • being reformist rather than revolutionary, which places them in the center-left imo.

    I disagree. That’s more to do with pragmatics than actual political alignment. Historically, leftist revolutions tend to get co-opted by corrupt individuals; the dictatorship of the proletariat has very little to prevent it from devolving into just regular dictatorship. A lasting leftist government needs to be constructed very carefully, which almost certainly can’t be accomplished overnight.

    Reformist communists want the same end goal as revolutionary communists, they just see a longer, gradual approach as being more likely to be successful and stable in the long term.