• @agamemnonymous
    link
    -1
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    That’s entirely beside the point. You think the fascists are more likely to give you ranked choice than the neo-libs? This line of thinking is nonsensical past superficial idealism. What’s your alternative, the greater evil? You think that’s going to magically make the ever-so-sightly-further-left corporate party turn progressive?

    How’d that work after 2016? If the wake-up-call strategy was going to work, that would’ve been the time. And oh look, we got a geriatric neo-liberal. Fun.

    I’m not going to wager a potential fascist dictatorship against the pipe dream that choosing not to vote is a cheat code that what, unlocks the secret actual Leftist candidate? What’s the praxis here? This is like sovcit levels of batshit copium fantasy.

    Edit: Downvotes, but no practical alternatives. Idealistic circle jerking.

      • @agamemnonymous
        link
        -44 months ago

        Voting for anything but one of the top two parties is pointless, voting for the lesser evil is marginally better than voting for the greater evil, not voting is tacit approval of the greater evil. Please tell me, exactly, how does “not voting for the status quo” improve anything? Not rhetorical. I’m asking.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          64 months ago

          Voting for anything but one of the top two parties is pointless

          Oh boy, do I need to tell you something.

          • @agamemnonymous
            link
            -34 months ago

            I need to tell you something: perfect is the mortal enemy of better. Both options are bad. One is objectively worse, if you don’t recognize that I assume you’re just part of Putin’s Geopolitik poisoning of the left, whether you know it or not.

            Smugly refusing to participate doesn’t make the options better, it just makes it easier for the worse one to win.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              54 months ago

              One is objectively worse

              Liberals are the most arrogant people on earth: you think reality bends to your will.

              you’re just part of Putin’s Geopolitik poisoning of the left, whether you know it or not.

              See, you’re just as fascist as Trump; neither of you actually respect other political positions, and both of you scapegoat all of your problems on a grand and sinister conspiracy by some scheming out group trying to ‘poison’ your superior in group. I wouldn’t vote for someone who says I only disagree with them because I’m part of the “Judaeo-Bulshervic conspiracy” and you people are not one iota less loathsome than that.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                English
                2
                edit-2
                4 months ago

                Liberals are the most arrogant people on earth: you think reality bends to your will.

                People who can’t make a realistic choice are far worse. When you represent an itty bitty fraction of the populace, you don’t have the right to dictate that policy be far-left. If you choose to not participate or to vote third party under FPTP, you are only hurting yourself by giving up what little influence you had. That’s just how democracy works.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  34 months ago

                  People who can’t make a realistic choice are far worse.

                  I have made a realistic choice, and it doesn’t involve voting for Genocide Joe.

                  When you represent an itty bitty fraction of the populace, you don’t have the right to dictate that policy be far-left.

                  Schrödinger’s Leftist: simultaneously an irrelevant tiny minority with no power, and crucially important to Biden winning, being wholly responsible if Trump wins.

                  you are only hurting yourself by giving up what little influence you had.

                  Unconditionally voting Blue means I have no influence at all.

                  That’s just how democracy works

                  No, it really isn’t.

                  • @[email protected]
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    04 months ago

                    Schrödinger’s Leftist: simultaneously an irrelevant tiny minority with no power, and crucially important to Biden winning, being wholly responsible if Trump wins.

                    No one is ever wholly responsible if the right wins, obviously. Wins are always based on a broad spectrum coalition, whereas losses are based on a coalition just barely failing. Modern US presidential elections are always close. Still, that doesn’t mean a potential coalition member gets to dictate coalition policy, especially when they’re on the extremes.

                    Unconditionally voting Blue means I have no influence at all.

                    Barring the demise of FPTP, you will never get what you want. Instead, politicians just learn you will never vote for them and they should look to more conservative constituencies. That, of course, means policies you don’t like.

                    No, it really isn’t.

                    It’s called compromise, and yes it is how a functioning democracy works.

              • @agamemnonymous
                link
                -34 months ago

                Stop acting like a state propagandist then. Stop suggesting that neo-libs and fascists are identical just because they’re both bad. -10 > -100, even though both are negative.

                Lack of nuance is evidence of idiocy or ulterior motives. I was being generous by assuming you had ulterior motives.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  24 months ago

                  Stop acting like a state propagandist then.

                  I’m not, what I’m doing is called ‘disagreeing with you’.

                  Stop suggesting that neo-libs and fascists are identical

                  I’m not, I’m saying you and MAGA are both fascist.

                  Lack of nuance is evidence of idiocy or ulterior motives. I was being generous by assuming you had ulterior motives.

                  Like I said, you are a fascist. I am far more afraid of people like you, who believe that any disagreement means you have “ulterior motives” than I am of Trump.

                  Seriously, explain to me why I should see you any different to Trump.

                  • @agamemnonymous
                    link
                    -24 months ago

                    I am far more afraid of people like you, who believe that any disagreement means you have “ulterior motives”

                    Ironic.

            • @zarkanian
              link
              14 months ago

              Voting for your interests isn’t “refusing to participate”. It’s the bare minimum in a democracy. It sounds like you’ve chosen to participate in a way which is counter to your own interests, and you’re calling out others for not following your flawed logic.

              Look, I know that many of the candidates I vote for are long-shot candidates. It’s highly unlikely that they will win. But if I don’t vote for them, then I’m part of the problem. I’m helping to make it even less likely that they win.

              Being part of the winning team feels good, but politics isn’t like football or hockey. This is an important civic responsibility.

              • @agamemnonymous
                link
                14 months ago

                Sure, if you live in a state where the result is obvious, then yes vote third party. But you know that they’re not going to win, and the only thing that accomplishes is visibility and possibly funding. You know that at the end of the day, the office will be won by one of the big two.

                My opposition is to broadly advocating that for everyone. Too many people do live in swing states to be flippantly both-sidesing an election where Project 2025 is on the table.

        • @zarkanian
          link
          24 months ago

          Voting for anything but one of the top two parties is pointless,

          I live in a blue state. Using that same logic, voting for Biden here is pointless, because the state’s going to go to Biden anyway.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          24 months ago

          Do you live in a swing state? Because I don’t. As far as I see it, voting third party won’t have any effect on the election, but might at least signal that I want change. It’s not like the popular vote matters in this country.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      14 months ago

      You think the fascists are more likely to give you ranked choice than the neo-libs?

      Do you really think that eh neo-libs are more likely than the fascists? Talk about “nonsensical past superficial idealism.”

      What’s your alternative, the greater evil? You think that’s going to magically make the ever-so-sightly-further-left corporate party turn progressive?

      Better than your idea. Also, I don’t care about ‘decorum’ and ‘civility’, so there’s not much difference between the two parties in terms of evil; the harm hasn’t exactly been reduced under Biden.

      I’m not going to wager a potential fascist dictatorship

      You really think submissively voting for the blue fascist every election is going to stave off dictatorship?

      What’s the praxis here?

      What’s yours?

      Anybody who votes for genocide Joe deserves Trump anyway.

      • @agamemnonymous
        link
        04 months ago

        Do you really think that eh neo-libs are more likely than the fascists?

        Significantly? Hah, no. Mathematically? Yes, absolutely. Extremely unlikely vs. “Oh, you wanted to keep voting? Lol”

        Better than your idea.

        Which is? I’m waiting.

        What’s the praxis here?

        What’s yours?

        Use every tool I have in the way it can be used. Voting for the lesser of two evils does not preclude literally any other action you could want to do.

        Anybody who votes for genocide Joe deserves Trump anyway.

        You think Trump would do less Palestinian genocide? He was pretty open about being very pro-Israel and very anti-Palestine. Genocide Trump would be substantially worse for Gaza, and also Ukraine too. That’s what “lesser of two evils” means: yes, Biden is awful, but the alternative is worse.

        Until you can show me an actionable alternative, I assume you support increased genocide of Palestinians and genocide of Ukrainians. Because it’s a binary choice, and refusal to choose against any option is tacit approval of every option.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          04 months ago

          Mathematically? Yes, absolutely.

          Well I got bad news for you, the odds are zero either way.

          Which is? I’m waiting.

          ??? You even need me to tell you your own idea?

          Use every tool I have in the way it can be used.

          What are you doing other than voting?

          Voting for the lesser of two evils

          Both evils are equivalent (and really they’re the same evil.)

          You think Trump would do less Palestinian genocide?

          He certainly wouldn’t do more. Also listen to yourself; you’re literally justifying supporting genocide.

          Genocide Trump would be substantially worse for Gaza

          Don’t believe you.

          and also Ukraine too

          Don’t believe you

          That’s what “lesser of two evils” means

          Yes, I’m well aware that people who say it mean that “the evil things I’m imagining Trump will do are worse than the actual things Biden is doing.”

          I assume you support increased genocide of Palestinians and genocide of Ukrainians.

          Oh, we’re doing this now? “I assume you support eating babies and killing kittens, thus making me the more virtuous!”

          Because it’s a binary choice

          Actually it’s not, and I know much it makes you fascists seethe that you can’t force me to vote for you.

          and refusal to choose against any option is tacit approval of every option.

          If you vote for Genocide Joe Biden, you deserve every horror you imagine Trump will unleash on you.

          • @agamemnonymous
            link
            04 months ago

            What are you doing other than voting?

            Voting is one more thing than you.

            Genocide Trump would be substantially worse for Gaza

            Don’t believe you.

            and also Ukraine too

            Don’t believe you

            Okay? So you’re uniformed or just illiterate? Your beliefs mean nothing to me, the evidence already suggests you’re a Russian State propagandist, or you’ve fallen for one.

            Because it’s a binary choice

            Actually it’s not, and I know much it makes you fascists seethe that you can’t force me to vote for you.

            It’s very simple math. If you can’t grasp it, maybe you should change your username to just “box”.

            So long as you continue to antagonize every leftist who disagrees with you, all you’ll ever have is impotent idealism. What exactly is your plan of action? Where is your grassroots, your revolution, if every mathematically and politically literate leftist is a fascist to you?

            I’m substantially left of center. Who do you think the proletariat are? How do you expect to mobilize them? How do you get three hundred million people to march in unison, when you call them all genocidal fascists? If they are all fascists, how do you ever hope to win?

            Except you’re compromised by propaganda, specifically designed to weaken the left (and the US) in order to empower Russian oligarchs. I don’t expect you to propose any actual action. I expect you to continue to insist that letting Putin’s puppet win will somehow rid the world of billionaire oligarchs.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              04 months ago

              Voting is one more thing than you.

              So much for mr “I’m using every tool”.

              Okay? So you’re uniformed or just illiterate? Your beliefs mean nothing to me, the evidence already suggests you’re a Russian State propagandist, or you’ve fallen for one.

              See? You’re every bit as much a paranoid fascist as any MAGA chud; why should I be any more afraid of them than you?

              It’s very simple math. If you can’t grasp it, maybe you should change your username to just “box”.

              Fucking. Seethe. Fascist.

              So long as you continue to antagonize every leftist who disagrees with you

              Project harder, fascist.

              What exactly is your plan of action?

              What is yours? Round up all the spooky Russians into camps?

              if every mathematically and politically literate leftist is a fascist to you?

              You engage in fascism, you are a fascist. Leftism is wholly incompatible with saying things like “evidence already suggests you’re a Russian State propagandist”.

              I’m substantially left of center.

              That’s bleak.

              How do you expect to mobilize them?

              How do you? Witch hunts against “Russian State Propagandists”? Telling them ‘Your beliefs mean nothing to me’? Maintaining that anyone who disagrees with you is actually a treasonous foreigner?

              when you call them all genocidal fascists?

              I’m calling you a genocidal fascist, you arrogant shithead.

              Except you’re compromised by propaganda, specifically designed to weaken the left (and the US) in order to empower Russian oligarchs.

              Great “leftism” there bro, totally not raving fascist rhetoric.

              Putin’s puppet

              Why not just blame all your problems on ‘Woke’ at this point?

              • @agamemnonymous
                link
                04 months ago

                You still haven’t provided any actions. Deflect deflect deflect, always complain that everyone else isn’t doing enough. Call them liberals, fascists, declare they’re not pure enough. Other them to draw attention away from yourself. Emotional, blaming, divisive language, anything to distract from your own lack of actionable content.

                No more deflection, no more distractions. You tell me, specifically, what your alternative action is. Tell me how it’s, materially, impossible to do while also voting against Project 2025.

                Or, prove me right by continuing to deflect. Go silent, or say I’m not worth informing, or you don’t have to explain yourself to some [insert political slur here]. Show the readers actual praxis, or show them that all you have is deflection. Your choice.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  04 months ago

                  You still haven’t provided any actions

                  Neither have you.

                  Deflect deflect deflect, always complain that everyone else isn’t doing enough

                  You’re the one demanding everyone has to vote for your genocidal grandpa.

                  Call them liberals, fascists, declare they’re not pure enough.

                  Would you prefer I call them all “Russian State Agents” instead?

                  Emotional, blaming, divisive language, anything to distract from your own lack of actionable content.

                  Worlds largest projector.

                  No more deflection, no more distractions. You tell me, specifically, what your alternative action is.

                  Right back at you, fascist.

                  Or, prove me right by continuing to deflect.

                  Are you 14 years old?

                  [insert political slur here]

                  Ahhh, I’m seeing the problem here, you think ‘fascist’ is just a meaningless insult, and not a word with a meaning.

                  Show the readers actual praxis, or show them that all you have is deflection. Your choice.

                  Right back at you, fascist.

                  • @agamemnonymous
                    link
                    14 months ago

                    You’ve made your choice then.

                    No actual plans, just deflection and calling people who disagree with you “fascists”.