Engineers are replacing a valve on the rocket that will power the first crewed test flight of Boeing’s Starliner spacecraft. The launch is now expected no sooner than May 17.
They’ve had two uncrewed flights so far. Both had issues. The first’s issues were so bad that NASA ordered the second (previously unplanned) uncrewed flight. That one had issues too, not quite as bad though.
Also, while their pad abort test was technically a success, it was only barely. Only 2 of the 3 parachutes deployed. You know, the same parachutes used for re-entry. Granted, that system has worked correctly since, and there’s always one-off issues. One-off issues being found are the reason for all the delays.
These are the guys in the industry saying iterative design (like SpaceX) is dangerous, and that apparently taking 2x the budget and 4x the time is the way to make it work the first time safely.
Boeing was the “safe” bet in this competition. They were supposed to have Starliner operational 4 years ago. SpaceX was the one expected to falter, being over budget and late. Instead, the SpaceX Dragon 2 has already made 23 launches (10 cargo deliveries and 13 crew missions) while Starliner still hasn’t made any deliveries or crewed launches yet. They made it to the ISS once, uncrewed, but it needed to be manually docked due to issues.
It really is quite fascinating how much Starliner has dropped the ball on something that was expected to be quick and easy. While these are completely separate teams and systems from the airplane portion of the company, it seems like the overall company culture may be preventing them from actually making good products that are safe.
For real though I’m not at all confident in Boeing’s engineering safety competence and rigor at this point. They have burned pretty much every single shred of goodwill and perceived competence they had built up over the course of the last 108 years.
The fucking beancounters ran it into the ground, and all they give a shit about is their golden parachutes and covering their asses from any possible legal liability.
I hope they can recover at some point. But if those idiotic finance types keep running the show, it’s gonna be on a downward spiral for a good long while.
Boeing, I hope that’s unmanned
Edit: no it’s not unmanned and knowing boeing’s track record with planes I hope this doesn’t end up being another challenger
They’ve had two uncrewed flights so far. Both had issues. The first’s issues were so bad that NASA ordered the second (previously unplanned) uncrewed flight. That one had issues too, not quite as bad though.
Also, while their pad abort test was technically a success, it was only barely. Only 2 of the 3 parachutes deployed. You know, the same parachutes used for re-entry. Granted, that system has worked correctly since, and there’s always one-off issues. One-off issues being found are the reason for all the delays.
These are the guys in the industry saying iterative design (like SpaceX) is dangerous, and that apparently taking 2x the budget and 4x the time is the way to make it work the first time safely.
Boeing was the “safe” bet in this competition. They were supposed to have Starliner operational 4 years ago. SpaceX was the one expected to falter, being over budget and late. Instead, the SpaceX Dragon 2 has already made 23 launches (10 cargo deliveries and 13 crew missions) while Starliner still hasn’t made any deliveries or crewed launches yet. They made it to the ISS once, uncrewed, but it needed to be manually docked due to issues.
It really is quite fascinating how much Starliner has dropped the ball on something that was expected to be quick and easy. While these are completely separate teams and systems from the airplane portion of the company, it seems like the overall company culture may be preventing them from actually making good products that are safe.
Honestly? If you got on a Max right now, you’re more than likely going to be perfectly okay. Thousands of those planes fly each day with no issues…
Safer than being a Boeing whistleblower anyway
For real though I’m not at all confident in Boeing’s engineering safety competence and rigor at this point. They have burned pretty much every single shred of goodwill and perceived competence they had built up over the course of the last 108 years.
The fucking beancounters ran it into the ground, and all they give a shit about is their golden parachutes and covering their asses from any possible legal liability.
I hope they can recover at some point. But if those idiotic finance types keep running the show, it’s gonna be on a downward spiral for a good long while.