The screenshot shows comments somehow being nested multiple levels without an intermediate parent. That’s a bug, right? Nesting should only be increasing by one level at a time.
I’ve observed this happening a ton across many different threads. There’s also some weird cases where the top level comment is just a link to “show parent” and… It’s not actually top level??
You must log in or register to comment.
My understanding is it has to do with deleted comments not having a placeholder, so the comments you do see look like they’re nested strangely
deleted by creator
This comment is in reply to a comment I deleted in order to test this theory.
This comments parent is this comment. And its content is:
This is a comment I plan on replying to and deleting to test this theory
This comment’s parent’s parent is this comment. And its content is:
My understanding is it has to do with deleted comments not having a placeholder, so the comments you do see look like they’re nested strangely
I think you are right. This reproduced the issue for me.
It’s bugged. Change your default comment sort to ‘New’, fixed it for me.
Hot works for me, top doesn’t.
I believe Top is completely broken, Hot is sometimes broken. New works.
I noticed that too. Changing comment sort didn’t seem to affect it, at least not that I noticed. It seems that it’s listing the newer child replies as technically newer than some of the parents, and sorting by new affected the whole tree, not just top level comments.
sort by top for comments is bugged. sort by hot and you’re good.
sort by top for comments is bugged. sort by top and you’re good.
Top is bugged so sort by top?
Hot*
