ID: A scene from The Good Place in two images. Janet is talking to Chidi, Michael is standing behind her. In the top image she says “Fun fact: Columbus is in the Bad Place” In the bottom image she continues “because of all the raping, slave trade, and genocide.”
I mean, you’re kinda hopeful at first because it has a couple great actors you know, but then it’s still WAY better than you expected!
Then every time you figure out how good it is? Nope! Much better than you thought it was!
This effect even persists throughout rewatching it all!