They can be set up in multiple ways. One way is that only subscribed people can view. Another way is that only mods can view. Most of the protests were set to mod view only.

I like it. It’s not perfect though. The community signup thing is confusing and stressful because you dont and cant know the core values of the owner of the instance you sign up for. So you could get comfortable in a community and then find that the community is not a good fit and have to abandon it. For some people, who have a ton of alts on reddit, that might not be an issue but I find it stressful when I was trying to sign up for lemmy.ml and then find out their stance on a few political issues that drastically clash with mine.

I also dont like how the moderation passes community to community. I kind of like the idea of a black list but when you have communities with vastly different views resulting in people getting banned from one community for things that wouldnt get them banned from other communities you have a recipe for disaster. Right now, even with increased usage, the amount of moderation required should be low but if/when this blows up there is no way you will be able to sort/sift through the shared moderation logs for every community just to make sure people are not being unfairly banned from your community. That would be like a small sub on reddit banning people from r/pics because they didnt agree with the poster’s politics.

I just dont like that. It’s far from perfect and I dont have any solutions and it’s also possible I completely misunderstand the issues involved… But from what I read… I just dont like that.

Functionality, everything works and I like how it looks. It has a mobile app that works. There is a lot of new content. It seems like it has a shot at being a replacement for reddit.

[email protected] is the link but it’ll probably be easier to just go here.

https://beehaw.org/search/q/ startrek/type/Communities/sort/TopAll/listing_type/All/community_id/0/creator_id/0/page/1

Which you can then select the one you want and it will take you to a link like this.

https://beehaw.org/c/[email protected]

Notice how it references the original link? the ! tells the site to view the community locally instead of opening it in it’s native location.

If you go to the site and view by new it’s just page after page of /r/askreddit. Tons of people posting to it with nowhere else to post. So that would explain some of the rebound but the graph is still odd that it rebounded to exactly where it should be if there was no blackout.

Honestly, mobile browing (even using old.reddit) has been garbage for years because they detect your mobile OS and constantly try to push their app on you. Click on link, do you want to open in mobile app? let me open the playstore for you. And then you also get limited comments. To see more comments open in mobile app… You could do a case study in how to alienate your customers into leaving your platform on just mobile browsing reddit.

I dont think it should be forced on any community and furthermore it should not be on the shoulders of the moderators for those communities to uphold. People should be voting with their feet with or without a community going blackout/private. A LOT of people are ok with the changes to reddit and a lot of people dont even use a 3rd party app. If a community wants to stay up during the blackout because most of their users fall into those categories then they should be allowed to do so without being harassed.

Like with most things in life it’s a two way street and not as black and white as everyone makes it out to be.

Personally, im out. I’ve used sync pro/ultra for years and I HATE reddit’s official app. But my viewpoints dont represent the views of everyone else either and if those people are fine with it then they shouldnt be punished because of my views.

I’ve almost signed up for this a few time but never felt the need to complete the sign up since there was always reddit… but now I’m starting to doubt reddit will survive unharmed. So here I am.

I just installed Jerboa for Lemmy and it’s passable on android. Not as many features as I would like but it seems to work well enough.