• @AMillionNames
    link
    234 months ago

    The official term is involuntary manslaughter, but it would only be applicable to the Witch of the West, however it would require recklessness or negligence, neither of which were present. Then again, when Dorothy’s house falls on the Witch of the East, although it’s basically a death from natural disaster, she proceeds to steal a family heirloom, the ruby slippers, from the deceased witch and refuses to give them back to her kin, the Witch of the West, so there’s some degree of instigation. That does not excuse how Dorothy is kidnapped and detained, plus there’s the criminal intent the witch has to kill Dorothy. It’s a shit show all around, but that’s Kansas for you.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        64 months ago

        What’s your argument? I’m all for twisting shit to make stuff isekai but jurassic park is just an island on planet earth with revived dinos.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          144 months ago

          The dinos are the isekai.

          “I woke up as a copy of my 65 million year old self in a land of apes.”

            • VindictiveJudge
              link
              fedilink
              English
              24 months ago

              They’re also not technically dinosaurs due to the heavy amounts of DNA splicing they had to do to make them viable, being more like a designer monster that resembles a dinosaur. There’s a ton of non-dino DNA in them.

          • lad
            link
            fedilink
            14 months ago

            That’s also cyberpunk from the dinos’ standpoint.

            a bit of nitpicking

            But that would contradict trying to be at least vaguely scientific-like because no memory would have been preserved

          • @Scubus
            link
            04 months ago

            Star wars is also isekai

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        34 months ago

        Because to make that argument, you have to reduce the definition to the point of uselessness. Jurassic Park isn’t Isekai/Stranger in a Strange Land because the island isn’t a strange, unknown land. It was created by the same people/culture the main characters are from. Isekai needs an independent culture with it’s own history and people.

        • @EmoDuck
          link
          14 months ago

          But then SAO also isn’t an isekai because all it’s inhabitants are just visitors from the real world and was also created by the same people/culture the main characters are from

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            14 months ago

            You’re right. SAO isn’t isekai. It’s just “Trapped in the game”. Although the Alicization arc is isekai.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      7
      edit-2
      4 months ago

      LOTS of popular western classics are isekai. Alice in Wonderland, Peterpan, The Chronicles of Narnia, Gulliver’s Travels all come to mind.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      04 months ago

      And here I thought that a key aspect of isekai was being completely unoriginal in every way

  • Ech
    link
    fedilink
    English
    214 months ago

    The first one was, at worst, manslaughter. The second was premeditated, but at the insistence and manipulation of one of Oz’s super powers, so she could probably get a plea deal if she’s willing to dish on Glinda.

    • lad
      link
      fedilink
      284 months ago

      That’s for the jury to decide

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        84 months ago

        Not really tornadoes fall under the heading of “Acts of God” in most southern districts. It would be dismissed by a judge before it ever went to trial.

        Grave-robbing (taking the Ruby Slippers) on the other hand would probably be a fairly sure conviction in Kansas.

        • @EmoDuck
          link
          24 months ago

          Grave-robbing implies that the witch was already properly buried and that having a house land on top you you counts as a for of burial in Oz

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    74 months ago

    She doesn’t really “meet” the wicked witch of the east, and it’s hard to argue that she “kills” her, either, considering that was an act of god which Dorothy didn’t really want to be a part of.