• @goatM
    link
    English
    319 months ago

    Communists defending Russia is one of the strangest things Tankies do. Why defend Russia of all countries?

    • @Socsa
      link
      English
      139 months ago

      Because they are campists. I’m still convinced it’s like 75% edgy teenagers, 10% state sponsored information warfare, and 15% right wingers trying to see how stupid they can make “leftists” look before getting called out.

      • @goatM
        link
        English
        19 months ago

        bruh there ain’t no paid shills on lemmy. there is little monetary or propagandist value in small websites. Really wish people (from both tankies and here) would stop saying this stupid shit

        • [email protected]
          link
          English
          29 months ago

          There are factually propagandists seeding atrocious ideas in nearly all communities, especially during and after breakaways like 4 months ago. Given the use of AI and scripting, and not to mention the nearly complete absence of countermeasures for either one on a relatively naive space like lemmy, a handful of people are definitely fomenting divisiveness. Subtle white supremacists, surreptitious state actors, website advertisers etc…

          Tl;dr: I’ve personally found a few sprinkled about.

          • @goatM
            link
            English
            19 months ago

            Can you link any of these?

            • [email protected]
              link
              English
              19 months ago

              About half of the accounts visible from this link. No clue whether they’re site advertisers or what, but they copy and paste identical threads across multiple social media platforms and steal twitter comments. It’s a pretty neat strategy, until you learn that it’s bog standard. Just the ones I noticed most recently, I usually don’t pay them any mind past determining their intent to spread divisiveness.

              • @goatM
                link
                English
                2
                edit-2
                9 months ago

                Oh, I know those guys. They aren’t being paid tho

                Yog is Dmitri, and he’s legitimately a weirdo who thinks Russia is some sort of vessel for the god-race or some shit.

                • [email protected]
                  link
                  English
                  19 months ago

                  You’re telling me that they’re doing this for free?

    • @[email protected]OP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      7
      edit-2
      9 months ago

      For Hexbear at least, I can see two of the reasons: 1) they support the idea of a polarized world where other powers are able to compete on equal terms with America. 2) They must present a united front to those outside, the “enemy”, because doing otherwise would provide them ammunition and weaken their own team. For having lurked long enough on their turf, I’ve seen more nuanced takes on Russia and China that recognize their wrongdoings. Even by the same users who’ll be total shills in a World News comment section.

      It’s a sport game in short…

    • squiblet
      link
      fedilink
      69 months ago

      Other than the possibility they’re shills, it seems to be “we oppose the EU, NATO and the US, therefore China and Russia are fantastic”. Which makes no sense, obviously, because making sense would be to oppose China and Russia for the same reasons they don’t like the US and the EU.

      • @goatM
        link
        English
        19 months ago

        bruh there ain’t no paid shills on lemmy. there is little monetary or propagandist value in small websites. Really wish people (from both tankies and here) would stop saying this stupid shit

        • squiblet
          link
          fedilink
          2
          edit-2
          9 months ago

          Oh, and I’ll add, I was told that on reddit in 2010… when there were people who only responded to threads about glysophate/RoundUp all day. Mention RoundUp, they’d appear. Around 2012, if you mentioned Israel, 2-3 people would come and argue with you about it. Around 2015-6, there was obvious astroturf about ‘Walk Away’ from the Democratic Party, anti Hillary Clinton, pro ‘Q’, and pro-Trump total crap. At all times: “bruh there ain’t no paid shills on reddit. Really wish people would stop saying this stupid shit”.

          So back in reality, people are paid by governments to spread any sort of discord in the US. They don’t care what site it’s on. I wouldn’t be surprised if someone wanted to discredit and manipulate the real left on sites like Hexbear.

          • @goatM
            link
            English
            29 months ago

            Reddit is huge, even in 2010-2012. Lemmy is tiny in comparison and has no monetary value.

            • squiblet
              link
              fedilink
              29 months ago

              Monetary value isn’t relevant, only manipulating people. Hexbear is the largest community of people of that political persuasion.

              In 2015-2017 they targeted gamers in online games.

              • @goatM
                link
                English
                19 months ago

                they’re not tho. Reddit’s communism subs are still larger.

                When you say that these fringe communities have government shills, you just look like a nutter, equally of a nutter as to when they think this community has government shills.

                • squiblet
                  link
                  fedilink
                  29 months ago

                  As noted, that’s exactly what people said about every community ever. “Shills? Manipulation? Nobody would do that!” except that various world governments funded divisions to do exactly that, it turns out.

        • squiblet
          link
          fedilink
          09 months ago

          Damn it, until now I thought there was no one who said “bruh”.

    • @Atomic
      link
      English
      4
      edit-2
      9 months ago

      Because they’ve idolized Russia for so long that to now admitt that they’re doing bad things is seen as a personal loss.

      And some just genuinly believe the propaganda being fed to them. It’s very difficult to admit you were fooled and led to believe things that wasn’t true. It’s far easier to double down and confine yourself to an echo chamber where they can all agree that it’s somehow because NATO or US sponsored the Ukrainian uprising and rigged the Ukrainian election.

      So when you think about it, they’re the good guys trying to restore order to Ukraine.

      So… if someone is on the fringe. Don’t insult them. Dont belittle them. Welcome them, and congratulate their strength to say “I was wrong” without making them feel bad for doing it. Not directing that to you, just a statement in general.

  • Th4tGuyII
    link
    fedilink
    249 months ago

    So they’ll take the word of Russia, a country who’s Government lies so much I’m surprised they haven’t been caught lying over the colour of their skies, over Ukraine who Russia invaded and stole land from underhandedly?

    Sounds about right for Tankies…

    Also, are they seriously suggesting Ukraine is the one using human wave tactics? Russia has thrown so many bodies at Ukraine that they’re struggling to find more bodies to throw into the grinder.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      79 months ago

      Also, are they seriously suggesting Ukraine is the one using human wave tactics? Russia has thrown so many bodies at Ukraine that they’re struggling to find more bodies to throw into the grinder.

      so many bodies the Ukrainians created the term ‘ditch meat’ to describe all the abandoned, rotting russians.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      39 months ago

      No, it’s for sure the country with I believe just under 1/3 of the population which is throwing as many bodies as they can at the front. Definitely. It only makes logical sense.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    159 months ago

    I love how they almost always close with something about NATO. They aren’t even fighting NATO. They invaded a country and they’re fighting the people who live there. If they were fighting NATO this would of been over laughably fast. They can’t even fight NATO donated gear 2-3 generations old used by soldiers hastily trained to use it.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    119 months ago

    Obviously the only two options in this war are that children die (because of NATO) or they get kidnapped to Russia. No other options, none.

  • @nanoUFO
    link
    English
    99 months ago

    I don’t get it why is 6chan in the title.

    • @[email protected]OP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      11
      edit-2
      9 months ago

      It’s an affectionate nickname for Hexbear. You might know that they behave like a bunch of 4channers, throwing and smearing their poop around; and Hexagon=>6 sides (must spell it out clearly, else the smart kids won’t understand)… both combined make 6chan.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        29 months ago

        can anyone explain why I keep seeing their garbage after attempting to block everything hexbear related? I don’t even mind the occasional tankie that much, but this lot is fucking bonkers.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          49 months ago

          Change your instance, i’m on lemmy.world which has defederated hexbear and I see no tankie posts.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            09 months ago

            had issues with lemmy.world for a while and went to lemmy.ee, will give that a try I suppose.

            I just can’t fathom why I can’t eliminate .hex from my feed lol

        • @yata
          link
          English
          39 months ago

          Lemmy and federation is very buggy. I’m from an instance which hexbear defederated from, but I sometimes still see posts from hexbear when browsing all+new. It seems like it doesn’t always get around to checking defederation when fetching new threads.

      • @nanoUFO
        link
        English
        -39 months ago

        behave like a bunch of 4channers,

        4chan isn’t tankies and 4chan isn’t just /pol/ there are plenty of boards on there that have no equivalent anywhere including reddit or lemmy like /lit/. I bet people on hexbear haven’t even read a book in the last decade.

        • @[email protected]OP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          5
          edit-2
          9 months ago

          I never said anything about political inclinations, it’s the trollish and toxic behaviors that are comparable. You even quote me saying “behave”. Don’t be *a Hexbear please…

          *Thanks for pointing out the typo, dear 6channers, much appreciated :)

          • @nanoUFO
            link
            English
            -59 months ago

            You say that and then you write that comment, kinda hypocritical no? Was I rude to you?

            • @[email protected]OP
              link
              fedilink
              English
              49 months ago

              kinda hypocritical no?

              No. Feigning to not understand, or distorting a point is something that Hexbear users love to do. That’s why I asked you to not be like them.

              • @nanoUFO
                link
                English
                -39 months ago

                At this point you are being intellectually dishonest and I don’t see how you can moralize with that kind of meta with responding to people. Goodbye.

        • @goatM
          link
          English
          49 months ago

          Of most extremists, Tankies are actually quite active in their reading material… Unfortunately, they don’t read to learn opposing views or even what historically occurred, but instead to bolster themselves in an attempt to appear smarter-than-thou, ‘Look at how many books I’ve read!’ – As if that means anything.

          • @nanoUFO
            link
            English
            19 months ago

            If it’s anything like the alt right Russian propagandists the reading material only includes easily disproven badly written propaganda and ignoring any piece of history that makes their country of choice look bad and twist anything negative to obscene levels. I don’t believe these people are history buffs nevermind people that fact check their “facts”. The only one up they have on people is that they have an argument ready for the most common attack vectors against their fascism.

            • @goatM
              link
              English
              29 months ago

              Pretty much. It’s interesting how every flavour of extremist is the same

              • @nanoUFO
                link
                English
                39 months ago

                I’ve argued with my fair share of tankies on reddit and you can never win even if you provide all the facts and sources. They will ignore them or say they don’t matter etc… etc…

        • Deceptichum
          link
          fedilink
          39 months ago

          4Chan is utter trash. Even the “best” boards are revolting.

          • @[email protected]
            cake
            link
            fedilink
            English
            19 months ago

            /an/ is cool, it’s just a bunch of stoners comparing snails and arguing about dinorsaurs.

          • @nanoUFO
            link
            English
            -29 months ago

            /lit/ is mostly clean I had made thread there that were 150 comments deep and no insults or slurs. You can also use 4chanx to filter comments too. Lot of stuff on /g/ is good too especially when it gets technical.

            • @yata
              link
              English
              19 months ago

              deleted by creator

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            49 months ago

            Isn’t that like saying not all cops are bad, the bad cops are just the ones you always hear about. (In the US)

            For sure, pretty much every individual cop I’ve interacted with has been very reasonable. Doesn’t mean the policing system isn’t rotten to the core when it’s protecting the bad cops.

          • @goatM
            link
            English
            49 months ago

            Most tankies are not reasonable, no. A few of them have legitimately put forth effort in engaging in this community, but when faced with the reality of Stalin specifically sending queers to gulags, they broke and reverted to their trollish behaviour, later returning to hexbear about their worries so their fellow tankies can feed them a false narrative about gays in gulags.

            They are not reasonable, or else they would’ve already tried engaging here–We have threads dedicated as semi-safespaces for them.