ID:
Orange, with Admin tag says:
I agree wholeheartedly. My assumption was that such behavior was simply a symptom of the relatively larger proportion of Europeans on this site, and their obvious jealousy and insecurity regarding Americans. I still believe that is the most likely explanation. To be clear, America has done hella dumb shit lately, and is deserving of criticism on many fronts. But what OP is referring to goes beyond that. It’s emotional animosity that overflows the bounds of reasonable criticism and targets individuals rather than governmental decisions or policies.
The number of times that I have seen people refer to the American contribution to WWII as cowardice, meaningless, etc, is too damn high. 400,000 Americans died in that war. Read a fucking history book you ignorant, insensitive fucks.
It’s certainly possible that there are agents in our midst sowing divisiveness, although unlikely. I don’t have any beef with any nationality, because I don’t judge people based on where they were born. That should be common sense, but it’s apparently difficult for some people to wrap their heads around.
Another user replies:
You think Europeans are jealous of Americans? You couldn’t pay me to live there, especially with Trump in power.
Orange admin responds:
Yes. America controls the world, and Europeans are salty about it. I didn’t even realize how salty until I started using Lemmy, but it’s incredibly obvious on here.
FWIW, I would be salty too. But you can also be mature about it and realize that the average American isn’t to blame for this reality.
Not sure if this is the right community for this, since I wasn’t banned (yet, anyway, and I seriously doubt my replies laughing my ass off will remain) but instead tried blocking the admin (but can’t, is that right?? If so, that’s power tripping on another level) and am seriously considering moving instance if this clown is in charge of any part of the one I’m on.
Definitely not the right community. This isn’t supposed to be about bad hot takes it’s about abuse of power.
Community rule 1. Post only about bans or other sanctions from mod(s).
Yep, you are technically correct. But the admin OP is talking about has a totally unhinged opinion on this topic imo, so it’s (maybe?) still worth discussing/exposing. I mean, people living outside the US aren’t “jealous” of modern day 'Murica… they are (mostly) appalled by it. Is this not common knowledge in the US for some reason? :p
I understand if the mods remove the post, but also appreciate other people understanding why I did post it here.
Do we need !shitadminssay ?
Still seems to belong here somewhat as another comment said
I don’t think those communities have ever not been toxic.
Definitely. Just saw someone else suggesting a LemmyHateUSA on [email protected], doesn’t seem that good of an idea
A little bit of toxicity never hurt nobody.
Dosage will probably be the issue indeed
I think admins making clear that they think Europeans are jealous of Americans leads some to believe that those admins are biased, and that bias could impact their administration of the site. I think this one is fair play, personally, because it begs the question of whether this person is fit to be an admin to begin with.
that bias could impact their administration of the site
If/when it does, post that here and it’ll fit in better.
Fair point
I disagree. If they have a pattern of behavior to suggest disagreement with them will cause them to abuse their power then sure but there’s no such pattern highlighted here.
Admins have opinions too. There’s no way to avoid it and suggesting that you’re only fit to be an admin if those opinions fall within a narrow palatable range is silly. Unless you’re an NPC you probably have some hot take that would be widely criticized about something. I think our culture right now is way too focused on these types of takedowns. They might be appropriate in a few cases but one bad opinion on something that barely matters is not one of those cases.
Admittedly the whole concept of an admin being elevated above other users is problematic in my view but that’s kind of a separate topic.
I don’t think we’re asking for admins to exist within a narrow palatable range, but we’re asking them to exist in reality.
And when their views are outside the bounds of rationality and reality, yeah, that’s when I begin to question whether or not that will impact things.
The whole argument about Europeans being jealous of Americans is fucking bonkers. If the EU had as open immigration as the US has, you’d see waaaaaaaaaaaay more US citizens moving to the EU than EU citizens moving to the US. It’s only skewed now because of differing immigration policies. Way easier to get into the US than into almost any European country.
The number of poor desperate people in the US who would give up almost everything to go somewhere they could actually get healthcare is too damn high. They simply don’t have the means to run away from this shithole. Ask me how I know.
But who decides what is reality? We all think we know the true reality but people have huge disagreements about what is or isn’t true. Compared to the spectrum of what many many people genuinely believe, your or my idea of reality is narrow.
But who decides what is reality?
🤦
If we were on a forum full of flat earth people you would see the problem.
But Lemmy is full of flat earther level thinkers on other topics. So it is a problem.
This is the same type of ideological purity that Lemmy.ml is infamous for enforcing. I don’t want to be like them and that means tolerating some opinions that are kind of stupid as long as they don’t hurt anyone.
If we were on a forum full of flat earth people you would see the problem.
No. Lies are still lies irrespectively of how many people believe in them.
Buddy, there is tons of evidence that this admin’s take is fucking hot garbage. You’re not convincing me with philosophy that this admin is anything other than a grandstanding idiot who will eventually let their heavy bias impact how they moderate the site.
Some opinions genuinely are fucking stupid, sorry.
And yes, playing this game of “wHo DeFiNeS rEaLiTy” is literally how USA ended with a felon as a President so shove it. Choosing to play that game is how people lose touch with reality and start believing total horseshit.
When you play that game you’re literally letting thieves and conmen into the conversation “to define reality” by their terms. Like Mark Zuckerberg asking Trump to prevent the EU from fining US tech companies. Whether you want to admit it or not, that stuff is what reduces belief that the people in charge are honest to begin with. People stopped trusting the US government after all the lies of the Bush administration in the War on Terror, all lies that were predicated on ignoring reality and substituting what the US claimed was reality. Playing the fucking game.
The aide said that guys like me were ‘in what we call the reality-based community,’ which he defined as people who ‘believe that solutions emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality.’ […] ‘That’s not the way the world really works anymore,’ he continued. ‘We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality—judiciously, as you will—we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors…and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do’.
Attributed to Karl Rove. Don’t play this losing game, please.
Admins have opinions too. There’s no way to avoid it and suggesting that you’re only fit to be an admin if those opinions fall within a narrow palatable range is silly.
If an admin of any instance said “this group is jealous and insecure about this group”, it would steer drama very fast.
They can say such things if they want, but not without their admin account, that just seems disrespectful.
I’m not saying it’s a good thing or that I agree with what they said. Maybe you’re right that they should use a different account. Is that normal for admins?
It does kind of open up the possibility of more abuse by banning people in arguments without it being obvious that it was personal. But on the other hand I guess that was always possible.
I already mod with alts because it seems unfair to have a discussion with someone when you appear as the mod with the big M.
Also avoid this kind of scenarios where I would have very debatable takes
*hats off
Good way to approach it, cheers.
This was my thinking too.
E: also the fact that I can’t block them is not ok.
They’re your instance admin, makes sense from administrative perspective to not allow blocking admins.
That said, there’s plenty of great instances such as db0 ;)
plenty of great instances such as db0
Great to block you mean?
If you believe so, then it probably benefits you and db0
This comm is in db0 btw
Taking into account that few threads down db0 was found removing a comment which didn’t break any rules, just simply because he disagreed with it - yes, blocking is probably the best. Until he is still a mod he shouldn’t be.
Which one of these lmao? Don’t see power trippin’ here.
spoiler
makes sense from administrative perspective to not allow blocking admins.
That in itself is a power trip (sure, if they are a sole admin of an instance, which they aren’t, they should have the option to dm any user even if they block them, but them being an admin doesn’t mean anyone should be forced to encounter their personal brand of bullshit as they scroll).
Either way, that on its own is enough to get me to change instance, and db0 is probably my first choice, I just need to gather enough brain spoons to make the move lol
Migrating takes two clicks if you’re on a computer.
User settings - export settings
User settings - import settings
Ok, thanks! What info does that bring along?
Mostly your block (communities and instances) and subscribe lists, which is usually the most important settings to use Lemmy.
Maybe crosspost this on [email protected] ? It probably fits there too
I think I’ve already overextended my available energy with what this post might stir up, I might just leave it now 😂
Crossposting is a click away, you can do it 😄
It’s not the posting that’s the issue, it’s what comes once you have lol
😂
I’ve blocked that whole instance. Too much bigotry coming out of there.
EU stands for Eastern USA
As an American, the average American absolutely is to blame for this reality. The average American either put these shit heads in power directly by voting for or by not voting against this reality in addition to everything else they do.
Yes obviously, but European politics is a shitshow as well, and that’s also due to the average European being an idiot. They also feed of each other. For instance I am from the Netherlands. In my youth (millennial here) our cultural identity was a culture of tolerance and liberalism. For instance, we were a world leader in gay marriage, weed decriminalisation etc. Now those that talk about “protecting our culture” seem to think that Dutch culture is more or less the same Christian conservatism you see in the US. I find it truly astonishing that a country were crossdressing was normalized in the 60s (if not earlier) now eats up US/Eastern European/Russian anti-LGBTQ propaganda.
While not European, SJW is Canadian, I was surprised too
Edit: if you well managed European instances
- https://sopuli.xyz/ defederates hexbear and grad
- https://lemm.ee federates them
- https://discuss.tchncs.de defederates lemmygrad
Yeah, that was my bad, and thanks, but I’m not necessarily looking for a specifically European instance, looking at dbzer0 at the moment, though still need to look in to how much of my current account I can migrate with me, and how.
Calling the French Canadians “European” is pretty good shade…
Lol, I honestly just saw the French language in the side bar and assumed, it’s generally not something I care about, so that’s my bad for sure, but either way, the fact that they admin a non-American instance is still a cherry on top of this shit pie.
That sound like another Russian.
There am ways going on about how theres definitely no bad actors on Lemmy and how “you shouldn’t care where one is from”
Saying bad actor’s sowing discontent don’t exist while he’s sowing discontent
More I see from USians, more I am convinced that the vast proportion of them is properly, certifiably insane.
Ah yes, Europe, where during the Enlightenment, a bunch of backwards fucking Christians said “people are having sex and dancing and that means we’re being persecuted!” Then they ran away to another continent, murdered the fuck out of the locals, and then built a country with the same fucking values of “Other people existing the way they want means I’m being persecuted!” which is like the US’s entire modus operandi.
